|
III. PROSPECTS FOR YOUTH
A. Introduction
1. Issues for youth in Asia and the Pacific into the 21st
century
Youth, as a distinct social group, are defined by the United
Nations as persons between the ages of 15 and 24 years.
According to that definition, youth constitute approximately
one fifth of the total population of the ESCAP region. Integration
and development of the full potential of youth carry a critical
importance in the development of the region. The Jakarta
Plan of Action for Human Resources Development in the ESCAP
Region, adopted by the Commission in 1988 and updated in
1994, identifies youth as the priority target group of all
human resources development efforts.
Issues affecting youth received worldwide attention in
1995 with the commemoration by the international community
of the tenth anniversary of the International Youth Year:
Participation, Development and Peace (1985). A special session
of the United Nations General Assembly was convened in 1995
to review issues affecting youth. In concluding its deliberations
on the subject, the General Assembly in December 1995 adopted
resolution 50/81 containing the World Programme of Action
for Youth to the Year 2000 and Beyond ("the World Programme
of Action for Youth"). The building blocks of the World
Programme of Action for Youth comprise 10 priority areas:
education, employment, hunger and poverty, health, environment,
drug abuse, juvenile delinquency, leisure-time activities,
girls and young women, and the full and effective participation
of youth in society and decision-making. The World Programme
of Action for Youth contains proposals for action in each
of these 10 priority areas and also identifies the possible
actors, including governments, non-governmental organizations
(NGOs) and international institutions.
The present chapter aims to highlight issues from those
10 priority areas identified in the World Programme of Action
for Youth that are expected to become central into the 21st
century. Four priority areas of concern for youth in the
Asia and the Pacific region were identified and discussed
by senior youth affairs officials at the Asia-Pacific Meeting
on Human Resources Development for Youth, 22-26 October
1996, Beijing, convened by ESCAP in collaboration with All
China Youth Federation ("the Youth Meeting").
These areas, which have been selected from the 10 priority
issues identified in the World Programme of Action for Youth,
are education, health, employment and the participation
of youth in society. The discussion of this chapter focuses
on these four issues. It first reviews several issues that
are expected to become increasingly important into the 21st
century in each of the three sectors: education, employment
and health. The chapter concludes with a section that provides
general policy recommendations applying to all of the other
three sectoral issues, and emphasizing the importance of
participation of youth in society and responsibilities of
the policy making bodies in the creation of an enabling
environment through development and implementation of youth
policies.
To provide a general background to the issue-oriented discussions
in this chapter, some recent demographic trends are briefly
reviewed. The global total of young people rose from 460
million in 1950 to 1.03 billion in 1995. This figure is
projected to increase to 1.3 billion by the year 2025. The
majority of youth live in developing countries, where that
portion of the population is estimated to have increased
from 768 million (81.5 per cent) in 1985 to 864 million
(84.0 per cent) in 1995, and is projected to increase further
to 89 per cent by the year 2025. As of 1995, over 60 per
cent of the world's youth were estimated to be found in
the developing countries of Asia and the Pacific
(figure 1).
The annual growth rate of the youth population fell rapidly
in most regions of the world from between 3 and 4 per cent
in the late 1960s to between 1 and 2 per cent in the late
1980s. Even among the developing regions of the world, the
average annual growth during the period 1985-1989 was 2
per cent, lower than the 2.8 per cent recorded in the previous
five-year period. The youth population growth rate was projected
to decline by 1995. East Asia in particular has seen a dramatic
decline and the region experienced a negative growth rate
in the youth population between 1990 and 1995 (Figure
2).
However, United Nations statistics for 1992 indicate that
the youth population growth rate remained high in the South
Asian subregion, standing at an estimated 2.5 per cent annually
throughout the period between 1965 to 1990. The subregion
also includes a few countries in which the youth population
is growing at a rate of more than 3 per cent per annum,
including Bangladesh (3.5 per cent) and the Islamic Republic
of Iran (3.3 per cent). On average, the youth population
constitutes approximately 19 per cent of the total population
of the countries in the ESCAP region, higher than the total
global youth population ratio which was estimated to be
17.8 per cent (1.03 billion) in 1995. Some countries in
the ESCAP region have even larger youth population ratios,
including Bangladesh (21 per cent), Indonesia (21 per cent),
Thailand (21 per cent) and Viet Nam (20 per cent) as of
1995. China and the Republic of Korea dropped out of the
list of above-20 per cent countries due to a decline in
their birth rates in recent years.
Further, many countries of the region have national definitions
of youth that cover a wider age range than the United Nations
definition of 15 to 24 years. For that reason, according
to the varying national definitions, youth sometimes constitute
over 50 per cent of a total national population. In the
case of Thailand, for example, because all those aged up
to 25 years are considered as youth, that group comprises
52.29 per cent of the total Thai population. These demographic
data add to the argument that human resource development
for youth should be a priority in Asia and the Pacific.
The discussion of youth in this chapter, focusing on the
four sectors of education, health, employment and the participation
of youth in society, is based on the premise that youth
are a positive force in society, whose potential should
be fully developed. The special needs of some of the sub-groups
of youth, especially those of vulnerable groups, however,
should be duly recognized. Among the various sub-groups
of youth, two deserve special attention in the context of
the ESCAP region: girls and young women, and rural youth.
Girls and young women in many countries of the ESCAP region
comprise one of the most vulnerable groups in society. As
the World Programme of Action for Youth points out, "girls
are often treated as inferior and are socialized to put
themselves last, thus undermining their self-esteem. Discrimination
and neglect in childhood can initiate a lifelong downward
spiral of deprivation and exclusion from the social mainstream."
Young women are especially likely to suffer from long-entrenched
discrimination, practices and habits. On the one hand, young
women receive little or no return for their huge contributions
to both the economy and society. On the other hand, young
women are often denied the same opportunities as men for
training and paid employment, and so are prevented from
maximizing their individual development and participation
in society. Fundamental gender bias, which is deeply rooted
in many societies of the region, negatively affects young
women in particular; and this has strong implications for
girls and young women with regard to the accessibility of
opportunities and participation in society in general. The
World Programme of Action for Youth notes that "one
of the most important tasks of youth policy is to improve
the situation of girls and young women".
The majority of the youth population in the region is made
up of young rural people whose roles in the development
of their societies are particularly important. Simultaneously,
the problems that rural youth face are often more acute
than those which confront their urban counterparts because
of the urban-rural gap in development which is predominant
in many countries. In many ways, rural youth in the ESCAP
region are one of the most disadvantaged sectors of the
population as a result of the general situation found in
the countryside. This situation is often characterized by
poverty, exploitation, lack of access to land, illiteracy,
lack of stable work, isolation, unsanitary conditions and
little participation in the decision making processes which
affect the lives of the people themselves. In most of the
developing countries of the region, the majority of young
people will continue to live in rural areas for the foreseeable
future.
The other aspect of the rural youth issue has to do with
the massive urbanization process now occurring in many countries
of the region. Rural youth are being uprooted from their
families and communities because rural-urban migration is
more likely to take place among youth than any other population
group. The ratio of the youth population living in urban
areas is steadily increasing and, according to United Nations
projections, will reach 53.2 per cent by the year 2000 (compared
with 44.8 per cent in 1985 and a projected 48.2 per cent
in 2025 for the entire world population). The issues affecting
rural youth which stem from urban migration thus warrant
special attention. In many countries of the ESCAP region,
rapid economic growth has created socio-cultural problems
that have impacted heavily on youth from disadvantaged and
low income groups. The desire to emulate the lifestyles
of the urban "new-rich" population, who have benefited
from the economic boom, has resulted in an erosion of cultural
values and the uprooting of youth from their families and
traditional values. Such factors have exacerbated the problems
associated with urban migration of youth, including drug
addiction, prostitution and HIV/AIDS.
Obviously, individual youth can belong to a number of sub-groups;
for example, a youth can be "female", "rural"
and "disabled" at the same time. Therefore, the
significance of recognizing sub-groups lies in comprehending
the special needs of a particular youth group, and especially
those of vulnerable groups, and not with dividing youth
into several categories. Rather than taking up the needs
and issues of sub-groups of youth in separate sections,
this chapter intends to pay attention to them throughout
its discussion.
B. Education
1. Enhancing access and quality
The World Programme of Action for Youth lists three main
concerns regarding the current systems of education in the
world. The first is the inability of many parents in developing
countries to send their children to school because of local
economic and social conditions. The second concerns the
paucity of educational opportunities for the more disadvantaged
sub-groups of youth: girls and young women, migrants, refugees,
displaced persons, street children, indigenous youth minorities,
young people in rural areas and young people with disabilities.
The third concerns the quality of education, its relevance
to gainful employment and its usefulness for assisting young
people in the transition to full adulthood and active citizenship,
as well as to nurture their idealism and creative thinking
so that they may become change agents in creating their
own future.
The Jakarta Plan of Action on Human Resources Development
also emphasizes the need for strengthening education and
training as the most critical process for increasing the
productivity of human resources. The proposals for action
contained in the Jakarta Plan of Action on Human Resources
Development embody a comprehensive view of education, encompassing
the formal education system at all levels as well as lifelong
education in the form of adult and continuing education
in non-formal settings. Training is similarly broadly conceived
to include skills development through post-school vocational
and technical training, on-the-job training and community-based
training. Broad-based training efforts are essential to
meeting today's rapidly developing technology and changing
needs of society.
2. Basic education
Basic education is important since it largely defines the
quality of life of youth, and the human life cycle requires
that basic competencies and life skills be acquired at an
early age. According to United Nations Educational, Scientific
and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) statistics, global school
enrolment expanded rapidly during the 1960s and the 1970s
at an average annual rate of 3.7 per cent, followed by a
slowdown to 1.1 per cent during the 1980s. In the ESCAP
region, all the developed and most of the higher income
developing countries of Asia and the Pacific have either
achieved or come close to achieving universal primary education.
But for the poorer countries of the region, much requires
to be done before the target can be realized. For example,
as of 1992, the gross primary enrolment ratios for Afghanistan
and Pakistan were only 31 and 44 per cent respectively of
all primary school-aged children; and in Afghanistan, the
ratio has dropped by 3 per cent since 1980. The asymmetry
of the data broken down by gender for primary school enrolment
is a critical issue, particularly in South Asia (see Figure
3). The gross enrolment rates for girls in primary education
in 1992 were 16, 30 and 87 per cent below those for boys
in Afghanistan, Pakistan and Nepal, respectively, although
the gap has closed by 12 per cent in Afghanistan and 15
per cent in Nepal since 1980. The gender imbalance as well
as the general levels of the primary school enrolment ratios
are also problems in some countries of other subregions;
for example, in Papua New Guinea, the male-female primary
enrolment gap stood at 13 per cent in 1992 compared with
15 per cent in 1980. In the Lao People's Democratic Republic,
the gap expanded from 19 per cent in 1980 to 30 per cent
in 1992.
3. Literacy levels
The prevailing education level of the adult population
represents the culmination of past investments in education.
In countries that have previously had low levels of investment
in basic education as a percentage of national income or
per child, any policy commitment to pursue rapid improvement
in the overall educational level requires investment in
adult education, particularly literacy programmes.
While most countries in the ESCAP region have achieved
considerable success in raising literacy levels, some have
made limited headway in this regard, particularly in South
Asia. Although the adult literacy rate in South Asia rose
from 46.6 to 50.2 per cent between 1990 and 1995, it is
still significantly lower than either the average 83.6 per
cent for other developing countries in the region, or the
average of 73.4 per cent for all developing countries (see
table 1 for country details).
The most urgent issue that requires attention regarding
the literacy situation of the South Asian subregion is gender
imbalance. In 1992, the literacy rate of adult women in
South Asia was only 53 per cent of the male population,
which translates into literacy rates of only 37 per cent
for women aged between 15 and 24 years. In fact, gender
imbalance in the levels of literacy is not limited to South
Asia, but is also found in some countries of Indochina and
the Pacific, including Cambodia, the Lao People's Democratic
Republic, Papua New Guinea and the Solomon Islands. Given
the important role of young women, and particularly mothers,
as the prime educators of future generations, an improvement
in the situation is urgently required.
4. Quality of education
The issue concerning quality of education has become increasingly
important. "Quality" of education for youth may
require attention to several different levels of issues.
Four different aspects of "quality" are discussed
as follows. First, at the most basic level, quality of existing
education is a concern in many countries in view of the
persistent problems of drop-out and repetition. The poor
quality of teaching staff, physical environment and teaching
materials often discourages students from regular attendance
at school and serves to increase drop-out rates. It has
been widely observed in the ESCAP region that national education
programmes concentrate on enrolment figures and fail to
implement remedies for absenteeism, drop-outs and students
repeating their grades. According to United Nations Children's
Fund (UNICEF) statistics, the percentage of children reaching
grade 5 in 1990 in South Asia was: Afghanistan, 43 per cent;
Pakistan, 48 per cent; and Sri Lanka, 92 per cent. In order
to tackle both the quantitative and the qualitative challenges
of attaining universal primary education, more resources
need to be geared toward primary schooling. In that regard,
India has announced plans to quadruple spending on primary
education over the five years from 1996 to 2000, while increasing
the budget for higher education by 50 per cent. The numeracy
of the general population in particular has been suggested
by many development studies as a prerequisite for economic
development.
A second aspect of concern related to quality is the efficiency
and effectiveness of the education system in providing adequate
productive manpower to meet the requirements of the rapid
socio-economic and technological changes taking place in
the region. Throughout the ESCAP region, and particularly
in South Asia, external inefficiency is reflected in high
unemployment rates among the educated. Inefficiency sometimes
takes the form of "mismatch" between qualification
of workers and the types of work opportunities available
to them. For example, tertiary-educated workers are sometimes
employed in jobs that do not require their qualifications.
Under the present rapidly changing needs of the labour
market, workers have to be equipped with marketable skills
that can be readily acquired. Advances in technology and
communications, coupled with demand for improved productivity,
present new challenges and new opportunities for employment.
Young people are among the most severely affected by these
developments. In that regard, close links with, and direct
involvement of, the private sector in skills training have
proven to be effective. Through the development of close
links with the employers, the mismatch of skills in labour
supply and demand could be effectively mitigated through
reducing the time lag between the education and training
of the potential labour force and the demand of the labour
market.
Further, rapidly changing technology and thus changing
demand for skills require preparation of young people for
multiple careers, which may be quickly adjustable in accordance
with market demands as well as their own choice of lifestyles.
Such flexibility most likely requires education far beyond
basic literacy and numeracy, and may be made possible by
providing young people with a solid foundation of self-learning
capability. However, such need for further education may
not automatically be translated into mandatory secondary
education for everyone. Conventional secondary education
may not be relevant for certain sections of the population
and thus perceived rightly by the parents as well as the
young people themselves as carrying a great opportunity
cost. Certain types of further education and training for
specific target groups of youth may be better provided through
non-conventional types of modality and actors, outside of
formal secondary and higher education. For example, entrepreneurship
development and specific training for self-employment would
become increasingly important, given the labour market situation
as discussed in the next section. Such training may be provided
as part-time training for out-of-school, working young people.
Other types of continuing education may be provided through
distance education and community-based learning groups.
A third important aspect of the quality of education, quite
apart from its relevance in the workplace, is its role in
empowering young people in the region. Education is the
key to establishing and reinforcing democracy and in promoting
effective leadership.
It is generally accepted that democratic governance relies
on three major conditions. The first is for society to have
a base of well-established political institutions; the second
is to have a body of citizens who possess a mature understanding
of the principles of democracy; and the third is to have
capable and responsive leadership. Educated young citizens
and workers have the skills to make democratic institutions
function effectively, to meet the demands of a more sophisticated
workforce, and to work towards building a better society.
Education empowers individuals because it opens up avenues
for communication that would otherwise be closed, expands
personal choice and control over one's environment, and
is necessary for the acquisition of many other skills. It
gives people access to information through both print and
electronic media, and equips them to cope better with work
and family responsibilities. It strengthens their self-confidence
to participate in community affairs and influence political
issues. Education gives disadvantaged youth the tools they
need to move from exclusion to full participation in their
society. It provides girls and young women, who are traditionally
marginalized from the mainstream of development, with the
knowledge and skills to function on an equal basis with
their male colleagues.
Aside from general education, the education of youth in
the processes of governance and the rights and responsibilities
of citizenship serves to instill a strong sense of commitment
of young people to the public interest, democratic principles
and civic responsibility. Education in democratic processes
through the demonstration effect of participatory institutions
within the learning environment, such as student representative
bodies, student parliaments and student participation in
school administration, are useful means of inculcating an
understanding by young people of the principles of democratic
governance. Further, training in such areas as independent
thinking, critical judgement, effective communication and
consensus-building, are essential elements for the preparation
of young people for effective participation in public affairs.
Such training equips young people with the necessary foundation
to function effectively in leadership positions.
Traditional approaches to education in the region, which
emphasize learning by rote, are generally not conducive
to the development of the above skills. It is time for governments
in the region to consider incorporating new approaches to
the educational curricula to ensure that the knowledge and
skills acquired by young people can be put to effective
use in promoting democracy and responsible citizenship.
Fourth, education for youth should aim at nurturing new
values for them to live their adult lives in the globalizing
world. Youth of today need to grow up as global citizens,
no matter in which corner of the earth they are born. They
need to learn to respect different cultures, religions and
ethnicities and be tolerant towards differences. Likewise,
young people should be encouraged to consider a broad range
of possibilities in selecting their own futures, including
their career options and lifestyles, and not be bound by
conventional values sometimes imposed by the existing formal
education systems. Existing formal education systems in
Asia and the Pacific, even the most successful, may be critically
reviewed in that they often pre-select "elites"
of the society at a young age and inculcate in them a narrow
range of possible patterns of "success" in life.
Such conventional value systems often discourage young people
from living in their own communities, particularly in rural
areas, and leave them to compete over a narrow range of
occupational options in urban areas. Given that the existing
trends of massive urbanization and insufficient formal employment
opportunities are expected to increase in the next century,
such a narrow value system is nothing but harmful. Education
in the future should enable young people to liberate themselves--their
ideas, values and options for career and lifestyles--rather
than tying them down with a limited range of possibilities.
5. Summary and policy recommendations
In summarizing the above discussion, it may be useful to
consider the major actors in education into the 21st century.
It would be important to recognize the continued primary
responsibility of the governments in providing educational
opportunities for the young people. Particularly in terms
of improving access to basic education, the formal primary
school will continue to be the principal vehicle for primary
education under the responsibility of the governmental authority.
However, in view of the resource constraints faced by the
governments of low income countries, other complementary
non-formal and flexible approaches are required in ensuring
universal primary education. In terms of improving access
to primary education, two examples are community-based approaches
aimed at enhancing educational understanding and support
of parents and other caretakers, and "second chance"
primary education for out-of-school children and youth.
Reflecting an increasing need for a variety of educational
opportunities to meet specific needs of different groups
of youth as discussed above, those provided by non-state
actors, including the NGO and private sectors, will become
important. In terms of job-related education and skills
training, involvement of the private sector will become
increasingly important given the quickly changing labour
market demand. Successful examples of countries in South-East
Asia, for example, prove that involvement of the private
sector in training programmes also helps to ensure the employment
of graduates. In expanding the range of available continuing
education, the further development of a variety of distance
education programmes would provide opportunities for out-of-school
youth. Governmental authorities should appropriately recognize
the roles of these non-state actors in education and try
to increase collaboration with them and/or facilitate their
activities rather than obstructing them with bureaucratic
red tape. Further, with regard to the evolution of education
that touches upon deeper values, civil society in general
might usefully play a greater role.
C. Employment
Tackling youth unemployment
1. Youth unemployment
Youth unemployment and under-employment are global problems,
being part of the need to create employment opportunities
for all citizens. However, there are several reasons for
the higher unemployment levels among youth compared with
other age groups. Unemployment in the ESCAP region is very
high among youth, with estimates placing youth unemployment
on average four times higher than non-youth unemployment
(figure 4); although considerable
concern has also been expressed in recent years about the
rising level of unemployment among the better educated population.
Among youth, unemployment affects both the educated and
the uneducated, suggesting that the problem is a shortage
of employment opportunities.
The factors that are specific causes of youth unemployment,
in addition to those factors that create general unemployment
include:
(i) A mismatch between the education and skill levels of
young entrants to the labour market and the requirements
of employers. In a number of developing countries, one problem
is the high drop-out rate from primary and secondary education,
which leads to an unskilled workforce that does not meet
the requirements of prevailing technology. Another problem
is the "overeducation" of youth in the social
sciences and the scarcity in technical training opportunities,
or poor links between such technical training and labour-market
needs.
(ii) Relatively high minimum wage levels, particularly
in developed countries and in the Pacific subregion, which
discourage employers from hiring young new labour market
entrants.
(iii) Discrimination against youth in recruitment because
employers value experience, proven skills and seniority.
The crisis of youth unemployment leads also to a crisis
of opportunities for young people independently to acquire
the minimum means for accommodation and housing necessary
for setting up families and for participating in society.
The early age of marriage prevailing in many countries of
the region, where nearly 80 per cent of women and 40 per
cent of men in South Asia, and some 50 per cent of women
and 30 per cent of men in South-East Asia are married by
the age of 24, has potentially serious economic implications
with regard to youth unemployment in such households.
Further, unemployment creates a wide range of social ills
that have damaging effects on young people, including the
lack of skill development, low self-esteem, marginalization,
impoverishment and the wasting of enormous human resources.
Such problems have become particularly serious in urban
unemployment in many developing countries of the ESCAP region,
because urban unemployment victimizes rural youth migrants
first and brings added insecurity, rootlessness and frustration
to this vulnerable sub-group. Young people who are less
educated and less skilled than their urban counterparts
are uprooted from the traditional system of support; consequently,
they are exposed to the lowest ranks of the industrial hierarchy
and have little say in matters affecting their working life.
In fact, they make up the sub-group that has become the
most adversely affected by mechanization and automation.
2. Youth in the growing labour force
The size of the labour force is expanding in most developing
countries of the region. Only in a few ESCAP countries,
most notably China, Singapore and Thailand, will the size
of the youth labour force decrease over the next two decades.
For the rest of the region, it is expected to increase from
an average of 2.1 per cent per annum in the period 1955-1985
to 2.3 per cent per annum between 1985 and 2015. The number
of youth entering the labour force will increase sharply
in countries with high fertility, such as Bangladesh, Pakistan
and the Philippines; the opposite will occur in some countries,
such as the Republic of Korea, Singapore and Thailand, based
on existing trends; while the region's overall labour force
is projected to approximately double over the next 30 years.
This has strong implications for the youth labour market
situation. According to International Labour Organization
(ILO) estimates, more than 100 million new jobs will have
to be created in the world within the next 20 years in order
to provide suitable employment for the growing number of
young people in the economically active populations of the
developing countries. Among other sub-groups, the situation
of girls and young women, as well as of young people with
disabilities, refugee youth, displaced persons, street children,
indigenous and migrant youth, and minorities, warrants urgent
attention. The problem of employment has worsened in recent
years and has affected developing countries the most. The
disturbing fact is that economic growth is not always accompanied
by expansion in employment opportunities. In that regard,
the Jakarta Plan of Action on Human Resources Development
advocates policies on labour-utilizing investment, including
those policies which support informal sector activities
and small-scale and cottage industries, pointing out the
importance of promoting self-employment and entrepreneurship.
In addition to the provision of suitable education and skills
training to meet the needs of the labour market, it is necessary
to emphasize a labour utilization policy based on the current
labour situation of the region. Further, support programmes
for emerging entrepreneurs, through provision of small-scale
credit as well as skills training and management and marketing
advisory services, should be provided at the grass-roots
level to encourage self-employment of young people.
3. Concern over child labour
Apart from the concern over insufficient employment opportunities
for youth, there is a mounting concern for some 250 million
children in the world "who often work in exploitative
and hazardous conditions and face injury, illness and even
death." (ILO/97/25 Press release). Asia has the largest
number of child workers, which is supposed to be approximately
61 per cent of the global total. The international community
gathered together in Oslo, Norway, in October 1997 to draw
up a strategy for combating, and ultimately eliminating,
child labour through legislative, educational measures as
well as through social mobilization. The concern is presently
focused on removal of child labour in its most intolerable
forms, including bonded child labour, children working under
conditions of slave-like practices, children in prostitution,
the use of children in drug trafficking and the production
of pornography. Among other hazards, since child labour
robs children of their right to education so that they remain
unskilled, their vulnerability in the labour market is likely
to continue into the latter stages of their lives as adolescents
and young adults.
4. Summary and policy recommendations
Past experience has shown that economic growth does not
automatically translate into increased demand for labour.
With the recent financial crisis and economic downturns
affecting a number of countries in the region, unemployment
has become an even more serious problem. Again, particularly
the unskilled young job seekers are likely to be hit the
hardest by this situation. Unemployed or underemployed out-of-school
youth are under tremendous psycho-social stress, which often
results in violence and other delinquent behaviours including
drug abuse. Facing economic difficulties, there is a concern
that more children and youth are lured into commercial sex
industry and other illegal activities. In particular, those
rural youth who have migrated to the urban areas without
successful employment opportunities are left in isolation
from the traditional family and community support system.
Under this situation, Governments should pay serious attention
to encouraging labour utilizing investments, including in
their efforts to promote foreign direct investment. In particular,
investment and job creation in secondary cities and rural
communities must be given support through tax incentives
and other policy measures.
Further, there should be support for young entrepreneurs,
particularly those who are based in rural communities. Facing
severe job situations into the 21st century, there needs
to be encouragement for young people to choose self-employment
as an alternative career to formal sector employment. As
mentioned above, credit provision and advisory services
as well as other incentives may be provided through local
government and other community-based organizations. Governments
should provide support to rural youth so that they do not
migrate into urban areas without good prospects of employment
and participation in productive activities. There should
be an effort on the part of the Government to coordinate
with local government offices to provide up-to-date information
on the situation of the labour market in the big cities
to rural youth gap and their parents. In this regard, the
Governments must be aware of the fact that young people
are likely to be influenced by the mass media. In its information
provision, the Governments must utilize the available mass
media as well as new communication technology, including
Internet, to effectively communicate its messages to young
people.
D. Health
1. The sexual health needs of youth
The most significant trends in the health of youth in the
region, affecting their social development prospects, are
in the area of reproductive health and sexuality. Hence
it is on these issues that this section will focus.
Today, adolescents increasingly enter into sexual relations
without much knowledge of sexuality, reproduction or contraception
and with little emotional preparation. They lack access
to appropriate advice and services and run the risk of unwanted
pregnancies, sexually transmitted diseases including HIV
and exploitation. This reality has become a subject of concern
in many national and international fora. Adolescent sexuality,
reproductive health and rights feature prominently in the
Programme of Action endorsed at the International Conference
on Population (1994). Yet, adolescents are neglected in
sexual and reproductive health policies and programmes in
many countries in Asia.
Improving the sexual and reproductive health of adolescents
is paramount but the obstacles are many. Firstly, the notion
that teaching adolescents about sexuality and offering them
contraceptive services will promote more sexual activity
is widespread and causes much controversy. Consequently,
governments are reluctant to provide sexual and reproductive
health services. Non-governmental organizations have had
to spearhead the work, but due to their limited scope and
capacity, these are usually unable to initiate such activities
on a wide scale or include a comprehensive set of services.
Secondly, most initiatives have had a narrow focus and have
been set up to deal with the biological aspects of reproduction,
leaving out gender roles and issues such as decision-making
and communication. Thirdly, relevant research data are largely
missing, making it difficult to initiate innovative programmes
or replicate successful examples and influence decision
makers to take action.
2. Risks and consequences
(a) Pregnancy and childbirth
In Asian countries, fertility outside marriage is not common
and fertility rates are thus correlated fairly closely with
marriage. In countries with early marriage such as Pakistan
and Bangladesh, fertility at young ages is high. Regardless
of whether pregnancy takes place in, or outside of, marriage,
there are serious biomedical hazards, especially for adolescents
below 17 living in poor conditions and where access to health
services are inadequate. The first birth to any woman carries
greater risk than subsequent ones, but especially for the
adolescent. Her risk may be compounded by her lack of experience,
knowledge and resources, and social and familial support,
compared to an adult woman. Too early pregnancy increases
the risk of maternal and child morbidity and mortality,
as well as the likelihood of having too many children too
close together. The risks in early adolescence are especially
high. At menarche girls have approximately 4 per cent more
to grow in height and 12 - 19 per cent more in pelvic growth.
They are at greater risk of complications such as obstructed
labour and death. Pregnancy-related deaths are the main
cause of death for 15-19 year-old women worldwide.
These risks apply to a married or unmarried girl but, in
addition, the trend toward more unprotected sexual behavior
prior to marriage has given rise to increased risks of induced
abortion, often in hazardous circumstances, and sexually
transmitted diseases, including HIV. Problems of chronic
morbidity and infertility and even death face the young
person who is not protected. The problems of early childbearing
are not only biomedical; they also reduce educational and
economic opportunity, especially for the young mother, leading
often to inadequate parenting because of immaturity of the
young mother and father. As a consequence, this may damage
the child and increase the likelihood of an adolescent pregnancy
occurring in the next generation. This both perpetuates
poverty and contributes to uncontrolled population growth.
Adolescent women are a large proportion of first marriages
and first births in developing countries. However, access
to information and services to prevent unwanted and too-early
pregnancy is the exception rather than the rule. It is often
mistakenly believed that information and the provision of
contraception with counseling will lead to promiscuity,
whereas evidence suggests the opposite. Furthermore, the
effective prevention of pregnancy is the best way to reduce
resorting to abortion, a common goal in all societies.
(b) Abortion
Because adolescents and young people are more likely to
hide a pregnancy, are unwilling or unable to seek appropriate
health care, wait longer in the gestation period to get
help and are more desperate not to have a baby, induced
abortion, or pregnancy termination, generally presents a
greater risk to the health and life of the adolescent than
to an adult woman. Adolescents may try to self abort or
go to unqualified people in clandestine and dangerous circumstances,
even when they might have had legal access. Information
from many sources suggest that self abortion, or seeking
abortion from an unqualified practitioner, is a choice for
a pregnant unmarried adolescent.
In most of the developing world, abortion legislation is
highly restrictive but, even in countries with relatively
liberal laws, impediments to service include: screening
procedures; the need for parental consent; lack of confidentiality;
and requirements as to where the abortion may take place,
who may perform it, how many doctors must approve of the
procedure, and its cost. All these will deter adolescents
from safe abortion. Because of lack of knowledge of, access
to and ability to use contraception, adolescents are more
prone to unwanted pregnancy than adult women. Regardless
of legal status, women who want abortions will seek to have
them. One can only guess at the numbers of abortions among
adolescents where access to legal abortion is difficult
or prohibited, let alone the morbidity and mortality rates
resulting from it, which are often unmeasured and unreported.
Abortion mortality is estimated to be about 70,000 women
globally per year.
A deeply hidden problem, but one for which there is very
little information from reliable sources, is the problem
of infanticide. Many adolescents, unable to procure abortions,
will hide the pregnancy and often childbirth itself, but
in desperation and fear of the consequences will abandon
or sometimes kill the baby, a practice know as "baby
dumping". The psychological impact of this on the girl,
whether she is apprehended or not, is likely to be highly
damaging.
3. Sexually Transmitted Diseases (STD) and HIV infection
resulting in AIDS
The young person who has sexual relations is not only at
risk of unintended pregnancy, but both she and her partner
are at risk of numerous sexually transmitted diseases (STDs),
including HIV resulting in AIDS. The awareness of STDs as
a major threat to public health has increased dramatically
since the early 1980s as a result of changes in epidemiology,
increasing knowledge of the serious medical sequelae and
the advent of the HIV/AIDS pandemic. Despite the growing
importance of this issue, only limited resources are devoted
to prevention and control. Adolescents are especially vulnerable
because of high risk behavior, greater biological susceptibility
to certain STDs and their sequelae, limited access to STD
treatment facilities, and the fact that primary prevention
is the only effective form of control for HIV and other
STDs. The World Health Organization has reported that one
in 20 adolescents and young people contract an STD each
year. The most common among adolescents are gonorrhea, chlamydia,
syphilis, herpes, genital warts and HIV.
Among sexually active young people, STDs are most frequent
in those who are youngest; and they appear to be increasing
throughout the world, although diagnosis and reporting is
poor. Highest rates for notifiable STDs are generally observed
in the 20-24 year age group, followed by the 15-19 and 25-29
year olds. However, in nearly all parts of the world, the
peak age of infection is lower in girls than boys. In many
countries, 60 per cent of all new HIV infections are among
15-24 year Old, with a female to male ration of 2 to 1.
An analysis of reported AIDS data from several African and
Asian countries suggests that young women under 25 account
for nearly 30 per cent of female AIDS cases and young men
for approximately 15 per cent of male cases. AIDS is spreading
rapidly throughout the world and moving into the younger
population. About half of all HIV infections have occurred
in those under 25. The largest number of infections is in
sub-Saharan Africa, but the biggest increase recently has
been in Latin America and South and South-East Asia.
Among the groups most vulnerable to STDs are young people
of both sexes who are engaged as sex workers. Many are literally
forced into this form of work and others choose to do it
in situations of extreme economic hardship or in the absence
of family or care givers. Both are likely to be patronized
by men who, in most developing societies, have more sexual
partners than women and are thus more likely to become infected
and to infect their young "clients".
The advent of AIDS through HIV infection has brought immense
new risks and challenges to society. The combined facts
that AIDS is incurable, lethal and associated with sexual
behavior, and that there is an indeterminate time between
HIV infection and death from AIDS, has made it an especially
sensitive subject. Young people are the last to be adequately
informed or provided with services to protect them from
harm.
4. Sexual Abuse and Exploitation
Sexual abuse (rape and incest) and sexual exploitation
(trafficking, pornography and prostitution) of children
and adolescents are prevalent practices in many ESCAP countries.
Large- scale child prostitution has been identified in many
countries of Asia. Brothel- and bar-based prostitution are
prevalent, although in some countries such as Philippines,
street prostitution is more common. Child pornography, though
less common, is also prevalent, particularly in Japan and
Thailand. Trafficking of children for sexual purposes across
borders is also rampant in the region.
Reports indicate that young persons are lured into the
sex trade by the age of 12-13 years and are likely to leave
their place of origin from 13 years onwards. Social and
economic conditions in the region are the foundation from
which the commercial sexual exploitation of children grows.
The generally low status of girls and women and their limited
opportunities to secure education and employment also leave
them extremely vulnerable to sexual exploitation. The growth
in sex tourism in many countries in the last few decades
is another contributing factor. Children and adolescents
are sold into the sex trade by families or friends, sometimes
knowingly, and sometimes through the mistaken belief that
the children will become domestic servants or otherwise
earn money for the family. Sometimes the children are kidnaped,
trafficked across borders or from rural to urban areas,
and moved from place to place so they effectively "disappear".
Sexual exploitation of children greatly affects their development,
in relation to:
Physical development, including the overall health, coordination,
strength, vision and hearing;
Cognitive development, including literacy, numeracy, basic
cultural knowledge, vocational skills, and other knowledge
required to live a reasonably successful life;
Emotional development, including adequate self esteem,
family attachment, and feelings of love and acceptance,
necessary to establish and maintain family ties as an adult;
and
Social and moral development, including a sense of group
identity, ability to cooperate with others, distinction
of right from wrong, respect for laws, respect for the property
and person of others, and other capacities needed to live
successfully within a social context.
5. Action to promote the sexual health of young people
For young people to be able to develop fully and to protect
their health, a friendly environment in which equity between
the sexes is valued, and in which young people are given
the support and opportunities they need to exercise their
capacities is required, and in which information, counseling
and other services can be provided in a confidential manner
by people whom they trust and who are empathetic to their
needs. Despite the fact that myths persist that knowledge
is a danger to young people, evidence suggests that giving
young people knowledge and opportunities for protection
through services make them more, not less responsible. For
adults to help the young, especially with regard to subjects
such as sexuality, they must be confident of their own knowledge
and comfortable with such subjects. However, few people,
including many who work in the health and education sectors,
are confident. Fear breeds misunderstanding and curtails
communication, while sharing knowledge opens the way for
growth. There are blockages in our systems of interaction
with the young. Below are some of the actions which can
be taken to overcome major obstacles. A useful way to develop
action using a multisectoral approach is to review the status
of adolescent health, adolescent behaviour and policies
and programmes currently available to meet needs and prevent
problems.
6. Enhancing young people's knowledge and skills
Young people are rarely provided with adequate knowledge
about their own development, especially in regard to sexuality,
the changing human relationships which take place during
adolescence, and the benefit to boys and girls of equity
between the sexes. They need to develop their capacity to
communicate and make plans and decisions during a time of
life in which their own autonomy is increasing. They need
knowledge about appropriate exercise, rest and nutrition
and the special needs of young women. They need to know
how to protect themselves against illness and injury including
the consequences of drugs, sexual abuse and exploitation,
and how to prevent pregnancy, STD and HIV infection. In
much of the world, young people lack specific information
about how to make use of existing services. They often do
not know what is available, where it is, how to use it,
what will happen when they get there, what it will cost,
whether it will be confidential, private or painful, what
will follow and, perhaps most important, whether they will
be welcome.
7. Youth-friendly services
Health and social services are all too often geared towards
adults rather than young people. They do not meet basic
needs of accessibility, confidentiality and low cost. They
are often not linked with each other. For example, a family
planning service which accommodates adolescents needs to
be accessible to both sexes, and it needs to be closely
linked, if not integrated, with an STD service, as well
as with maternal health care. Services in one sector are
frequently inadequately linked with interventions in other
sectors. Furthermore, the provision of information, education
and communication to young people in general is rarely linked
with the health services locally available. By and large,
young people either do not use services which exist or come
later when help is more difficult. Their experience is often
a negative one, and word of mouth keeps other youngsters
away. Health and social services, therefore, need to be
accessible to young people to promote health, and especially
to intercept problems at an early stage for human, health
and economic reasons.
8. Peer education and counselling
Peer education and peer counselling are two ways to assist
young people in obtaining the help they need. Young people
are widely used to help meet the information requirements
of other young people as they are more likely not to reprimand
them for their questions, and may well be more understanding
of the need for information than adults. To do this well,
however, requires a partnership with adults, initially,
to help obtain and provide sound information from reliable
sources, and for support to the young people providing such
help, since they may be faced with situations which require
more than straightforward information. Peer counselling
is harder to achieve, since it requires special training
in counselling and psychological skills, adequate knowledge
of adolescent needs, ways to meet these needs and how to
know when to refer to others. This requires training, supervision
and above all continuing support, since it can be a stressful
and very demanding task.
9. Prevention of sexual abuse and exploitation of children
There are four levels of potential actions that can be
considered: primary prevention; secondary prevention; tertiary
prevention; and rehabilitation. Primary prevention of sexual
exploitation and abuse of children and adolescents involves
promoting health development and the establishment of healthy
lifestyles. The main features of this level of prevention
includes specific policies, the provision of information
through a variety of channels, and education. The information
can be given by means of one-way channels of communication,
such as radio, television, cartoons, magazines, videos and
films or two-way communication - in person or by telephone.
The latter channel of communication is more effective since
it permits the young person to ask questions and explore
issues of special individual significance.
In secondary prevention, the aim is to identify and reduce
the risk of children and adolescents from becoming more
vulnerable to sexual abuse and exploitation, by providing
basic services, such as education, health care, shelter,
employment and capital for income generating activities,
to especially disadvantaged families, women and children.
Secondary prevention is only effective if children and adolescents
are reached early enough to eliminate the factors that put
them at risk.
Tertiary prevention includes treatment and compensatory
support which is provided to children who have already suffered
sexual abuse or exploitation but where the damage suffered
is not permanent. A key element in this level of prevention
is the availability and accessibility of treatment and support.
Complications can be prevented or cured much more easily
if the children or adolescents understand the problem and
if those providing the care are aware of the special needs
and perceptions of the children seeking care. These services
tend to be non-institutionalized and are usually small NGO
projects or local community initiatives.
Rehabilitation is necessary for children in situations
of permanent or near-permanent difficulty. Such circumstances
would include disability, mental impairment from drugs and
alcohol abuse, absence of families or effective ties, criminal
behavior and persistent conflicts with the law.
Experts and professionals have some of the answers needed
to reduce the problems associated with adolescent sexuality
and sexual exploitation. But they need the cooperation and
support of policy makers, who are often misinformed or ill-advised,
to make any impact. Change is needed in institutions, laws
and policies if the needs of young people are to be better
met. Most initiatives for children and adolescents have
been undertaken by NGOs, while the magnitude of the problems
associated with adolescent sexuality and sexual exploitation
demand that they are addressed at the highest levels of
policy and planning by governments and international agencies.
10. Coherent policy and legislation
There are many kinds of policies, laws and regulations
which affect the health care and health behaviours of young
people. These need to be consistent with one another, to
be understood by those who are affected by them, and to
be implemented. Unfortunately much legislation of this kind
has been created on an ad hoc basis, without focus on the
overall welfare of the young person. They are frequently
not known by those most affected by them, or may be misunderstood,
and are inconsistently implemented. There are many kinds
of laws and regulations which affect young people, including:
the minimum age for each sex at which marriage and/or sexual
relations are permitted; whether adult consent is required
for the use of services or access to contraception; laws
regarding the sale and consumption of tobacco, alcohol and
other drugs; and laws which are designed to protect them,
such as those stipulated in the Convention on the Rights
of the Child and the Convention for the Elimination of All
Forms of Discrimination Against Women, on condition that
their country has ratified these international instruments.
A helpful step in each country is a cross-sectoral review
of adolescent health policy, to identify whether explicit
policy exists in the public sector.
E. Participation of youth in society
1. Policies to meet the needs of youth
As the World Programme of Action for Youth states, the
progress of society depends, to a considerable extent, on
its capacity to incorporate the contribution and responsibility
of youth in the building and designing of its future. In
addition to mobilizing the capacity of youth for supporting
today's development policies, their unique perspectives
of the immediate future need to be taken into account in
the formulation of long-term policies.
The economic, social and political participation of youth
largely determines the effectiveness of actions proposed
in the World Programme of Action for Youth. As the Jakarta
Plan of Action on Human Resources Development advocates,
both the means and the results of development should be
people-centred, and young people should be given an appropriate
position in society to allow them to express their views
on the improvement of the social, economic and cultural
aspects of society. Policies should be geared toward creating
an atmosphere among young people that provides possibilities
for bringing about improvements in their own lives and for
the future of society as a whole.
Table 2 provides some indicators
on youth participation in society.
2. Youth policies
In order to develop fully the aspirations of youth for
people-centred development of society, policy makers need
to first understand the problems and needs of youth. Policy
and programme formulation needs to start with appropriate
decision-taking by youth at all levels, including communities,
schools and universities at the provincial and national
levels, through such means as voting and the provision of
appropriate status to youth organizations and leaders.
Based on that understanding, it is an important responsibility
of policy makers to develop and implement youth policies
that are conducive to youth participation. Effective youth
policies can play a major role in creating an "enabling"
environment for youth to develop their full potentials and
aspirations.
Why do countries need youth policies? The World Programme
of Action for Youth identifies some of the reasons why a
specific policy for youth is necessary:
Young people in all countries are both a major human resource
for development and key agents for social change, economic
development and technological innovation. Their imagination,
ideals, considerable energies and vision are essential for
the continuing development of the societies in which they
live. The problems that young people face as well as their
vision and aspirations are an essential component of the
challenges and prospects of today's societies and future
generations. Thus, there is special need for new impetus
to be given to the design and implementation of youth policies
and programmes at all levels. The ways in which the challenges
and potentials of young people are addressed by policy will
influence current social and economic conditions and the
well-being and livelihood of future generations.
However, for a youth policy to ensure the development of
youth as prescribed in the World Programme of Action for
Youth, several conditions should be met in its formulation
and implementation. First, the policy makers should have
objectives in formulating youth policies that are conducive
to the development of youth's potential and promotion of
their active participation in society. In the survey undertaken
by the ESCAP Secretariat on the status of youth policies
in the region, it was found that most of the countries of
the ESCAP region recognize youth as a positive force. As
such, they are focusing their youth policy objectives on
the development of the full potential of that portion of
their human resource pool in order to ensure the maximum
contribution of youth to the development of their societies.
In that regard, most countries recognize the importance
of providing a suitable environment for the active participation
of youth in society. However, the concept of "participation"
of youth seems to vary among the countries of the region.
Only a limited number of countries clearly include participation
of youth in the decision-making process as a part of the
objectives of their youth policies. It should be noted that
the concept of "participation of youth in national
development" should not be interpreted as a means of
exploitation and utilization of youth human resources for
national development. It should rather imply the participation
of youth themselves in the decision-making process of national
development. In other words, rather than perceiving youth
from a purely objective perspective as resources for national
development, it is important to view youth from a subjective
perspective as stake-holders and members of society.
Second, while it is important that national youth policy
be formulated as independent legislation, it is necessary
for countries to integrate such policy into the overall
development picture. A policy for youth needs to be related
to and coordinated with other national and social policies,
and integrated into the overall strategy for development,
and it is essential that the particular needs and problems
of youth be considered as an integral part of the national
planning and policy-making process. A major step towards
integration is to ensure that youth policy is not isolated
from the other objectives of the national development plan,
but incorporated into the documents of the national development
plan. A national youth policy should not be treated as a
separate plan for young people. It should act across sectoral
lines so that the needs of youth and the implications of
policies on youth are duly recognized in each of the sectoral
development plans. Without the mainstreaming of national
youth policy, backed by an appropriate budget allocation
and infrastructure for implementation, policy formulation
becomes perhaps a futile exercise. In short, in order for
youth policy to be truly effective, youth policy should
be developed as independent legislation, while at the same
time it should be closely integrated into the overall strategy
for national development. Further, it is necessary to involve
related agencies and ministries in the initial policy formulation
stage in order to enlist the collaboration of these agencies
in the implementation stage.
Third, policy makers should be mindful of the fact that
the implementation of policies and programmes for youth
should encompass a broad range of sectors in society, and
so require extensive involvement and coordination with a
large number of governmental as well as non-governmental
actors. Youth policies encompass all facets of life and,
for that reason, in addition to the integration of a youth
policy into the overall national development framework,
appropriate collaborative mechanisms should be put in place
at the stage of policy formulation. Policy implementation
requires concerted efforts by a number of ministries, agencies
and non-governmental bodies. To bring about a collaborative
relationship of that nature at the time of implementation,
the formulation of policy documents should also involve
appropriate consultation and collaboration among the various
bodies concerned since they will have to work within the
general framework of the national development policy. In
this respect, it is noteworthy that the survey conducted
by ESCAP revealed that in many countries the youth policy
formulation process involved a number of parties, most notably
youth organizations (12 countries). According to the responses
from other countries, Parliamentary Commissions, the judiciary,
law enforcement, political parties, universities and research
centres, religious and local communities, and local government
had been involved in the youth policy formulation process.
However, coordination in implementation of policies and
programmes still remains a major challenge. Experience has
shown that the task of coordinating has been an overwhelming
function for the national focal point agency, given that
most are newly established and lack strong financial backing.
In this connection, it may be useful to note the suggestions
of the 1993 study by the United Nations on the global situation
of youth in the 1990. The study points out that basic conditions
have to be fulfilled in order for coordination mechanisms
to function effectively. These include: (a) an adequate
commitment to, and adequate instruments for, furthering
youth policy objectives; (b) a capacity to coordinate on-going
activities and to identify areas requiring attention and
developmental effort; and (c) development of the proper
organizational balance by sufficient government, non-governmental
and youth representation. Further, based on past regional
experience, it may be concluded that the organizational
location, that is, the level of government authority attached
to the focal point agency, together with the level of budgetary
support, are critical factors that influence the effectiveness
of the agency as a coordinating body.
Fourth, the institutional strengthening and appropriate
positioning of youth focal point agencies should be considered
for effective implementation of youth policies. One strategy,
advocated during the International Youth Year: Participation,
Development, Peace, was the need to establish appropriate
coordination mechanisms within each country in order to
encourage the integration of youth issues into overall national
development planning. In response to this advocacy, numerous
Governments in the region formulated youth policies and
created ministries, councils, departments, secretariats
and offices which, in many cases, were granted a high level
of government authority to promote and implement national
youth policies.
However, the mechanisms for implementing youth policies
appear to be in need of review in many countries. Ministries
or departments responsible for youth affairs are often charged
with responsibility for developing policies and programmes
which address the mass of unemployed youth, while being
left in weak financial and political positions with regard
to the coordination of youth activities with other line
ministries and NGOs. Even when the coordination efforts
with other ministries are successful, the necessary support
is often only provided when surplus resources are available
after each sectoral ministry has implemented its own programmes.
Therefore, in many countries where strong political commitment
is absent, youth ministries tend to limit themselves to
peripheral activities concerning youth: recreation, culture,
sports and mobilization of youth organizations for specific
projects. While the creation of youth ministries and equivalent
agencies is, in a sense, a manifestation of government support
for youth development, the strategic positioning of such
institutions, together with adequate financial backing,
appears essential to their full and effective functioning.
Fifth, it should be noted by policy makers that they should
aim at creating an "enabling" environment through
youth policy for different actors to play their roles and
realize their aspirations rather than constraining them.
In other words, a youth policy should aim, inter alia, towards
the promotion of non-governmental youth organizations, by
setting up a clear framework for their activities. This
may be done by the articulation of a broad but clear policy
framework that allows room for flexibility in programme
development to tap the creative talents of the concerned
parties involved in youth affairs, particularly youth NGOs.
The important role of youth policy, in addition to providing
an overall framework and direction for youth activities,
is to promote the involvement of a wide range of actors,
including government, NGOs, the private sector and youth
themselves. According to a 1992 report by the Commonwealth
Secretariat, a "youth policy should spell out only
the broad parameters of work and the general outline of
action so that the implementing agencies, especially the
NGOs, have adequate scope and freedom to evolve their own
programmes and activities on the basis of their philosophy
of work, objectives, needs of the beneficiary groups and
position of resources." By setting up a clear but broad
framework for programme development, a youth policy serves
as an effective instrument for mobilizing the different
parties concerned in a country, particularly youth organizations,
in planning and implementing youth programmes.
A number of initiatives have been taken in the Asian and
Pacific region during the course of the decade following
International Youth Year in 1985. However, in terms of formulation
and implementation of national youth policies and establishment
of youth ministries, which were the major recommendations
emanated from the observance of the Year, many countries
have only begun to take action to set up youth policies
and youth ministries and agencies in the 1990s. In addition,
the newly developed youth policies have yet to be fully
integrated into the overall national development strategies.
Youth policies are among the newest type of legislation
in many countries of the region, and there is a high demand
for regional sharing of experience in their formulation
and implementation. The possibilities for regional cooperation
in this field, particularly through networking of youth
organizations, both governmental and non-governmental, are
tremendous. The time is ripe for governments and NGOs to
forge ahead with such initiatives.
3. Participation of youth organizations and NGOs
The World Programme of Action for Youth stresses that youth
organizations are an important vehicle for development of
participation by youth in leadership, promotion of tolerance,
and increasing cooperation and exchanges between youth organizations.
Youth organizations can provide effective means and opportunities
for youth to participate in the mainstream of society. Youth
organizations that are closely linked with the communities
can bring about the melding of distinctly different issues
and concerns of rural and urban youth. While a number of
Governments in the region involve youth organizations in
the formulation and implementation of youth policies, existing
collaborative structures between the government and non-government
sectors need to be re-examined and improved.
Many adults believe that young people are the cause of
social problems, not the solution; they believe that providing
youth with information and knowledge poses a threat to social
stability. But the promotion of the health and education
of adolescents actually offers tremendous benefits for the
public good while also helping youth to fulfil their own
potential. The nature of the relationship between adults
and adolescents is at the heart of the matter. A positive
outlook by an adult is more likely to elicit a positive
reaction in an adolescent. For this to happen, there are
at least two prerequisites; the basic needs of young people
must be met and the opportunity to use their capacities
must be provided.
The following areas require improvement on the part of
the Governments: formulation of a curriculum of formal education
that incorporates survival skills in the context of current
socio-economic realities; recognition and appreciation of
youth initiative; greater access to information; education
and skills training for youth empowerment; and the granting
of greater priority to youth programmes.
NGOs are an important channel for youth participation in
development. Many NGOs are in regular contact with young
people and thus are in a better position to mobilize them
for constructive activities at the local and national levels.
They are often run by extremely dedicated and experienced
youth leaders. What the NGOs need is a wider range of opportunities
and recognition by the general public so that the vast resource
of energy which youth represents can be put to its best
use for society. This can only be done by political will,
mutual trust between Governments and NGOs, and networking
of youth organizations at the local and national levels.
A Youth Ministry or its equivalent in each country could
take much of the responsibility in facilitating and preparing
such an infrastructure for youth NGOs. Networking, in particular,
helps to mobilize NGOs in different fields and with different
goals in identifying and tackling common social problems
such as drug abuse and HIV/AIDS.
An effective approach to networking should be bottom-up,
not top-down, because needs and ideas of development reside
with grass-roots experiences. It is at the district level
downwards that the beneficiary groups of development are
located and it is towards them that programmes should be
aimed. To strengthen youth NGOs, the Governments should
facilitate their free and uninhibited functioning, feeding
their trial-and-error results into the formation of broad
national goals. Although some Governments have schemes for
giving grants-in-aid to NGOs, an even greater share should
go to those working with young people, especially young
women. Those NGOs should also be provided with technical
support and training facilities for their personnel. Governments
could also set up a liaison body among NGOs and between
the government and NGOs.
At the micro-level, particularly regarding the participation
of rural youth in development, it is essential that a network
of small-sized and often non-registered youth clubs (which
may be based on agricultural cooperatives, political parties,
local chambers of commerce or even Internet circles) be
created so that rural youth can be associated with the delivery
of the development programme benefits. The youth clubs could
act as watch-dogs for the implementation of national and
district-level programmes. Ideally, all three participating
groups (Governments, NGOs and youth organizations), have
complementary roles and responsibilities in providing an
infrastructure for youth participation in development.
In summary, efforts should be made to ensure better coordination,
not only among government agencies but also between government
and NGOs. Existing youth organizations need to be further
developed. Non-governmental organizations have played a
key role in reaching out to young people with programmes
and services as well as in representing their interests.
Youth organizations should not be viewed merely as an arm
of governmental organizations to be used in reaching the
youth population. A youth policy should actually be structured
in such a way as to encourage creativity and initiative
of youth organizations. Governmental support for youth organizations
could take a variety of forms and not just be limited to
financial assistance. Such support could be in the form
of services and expertise in the planning and implementation
of the organizations' activities, bearing in mind the need
to maintain the independence of such organizations. One
method would be to support a network of youth organizations
as a forum for exchanging views and experiences, and for
providing opportunities for resource sharing.
F. Conclusion
This chapter focused on emerging issues and trends that
are considered to become increasingly important for youth
in Asia and the Pacific into the 21st Century. It highlighted
2-3 issues each in the four priority areas of concern for
youth in the Asia and the Pacific region, namely, education,
employment, health and youth participation, and pointed
to some of the new policy considerations in view of those
emerging issues. Thus the discussion in this chapter is
by no means meant to be comprehensive in its nature.
The four priority areas have been chosen from the 10 issues
identified in the World Programme of Action for Youth, taking
into account the situation of youth in the region. In terms
of education, enhancement of access to basic education is
still a major concern in many countries in the region, particularly
in South Asia and especially among girls. Since universal
access to basic education is a prerequisite for any further
advancement in education for youth, the current issue of
"access" must be tackled urgently so that the
increasingly important issues of "quality" may
be granted more attention. The chapter discusses different
aspects of "quality" and calls the attention of
the policy makers to traditionally neglected aspects, such
as education to harness democratic ideas, responsible citizenship,
and creativity among young people. It also suggests the
importance of roles to be played by non-state actors.
In the area of employment, the current status of severe
unemployment among youth is expected to continue or even
be further aggravated in the near future in view of the
recent economic crisis affecting a number of countries in
the region. Governments need to review their policies to
promote labour-utilizing investments as called for in the
Jakarta Plan of Action on Human Resources Development. Moreover,
under the severe labour market situation which is expected
to aggravate into the next century, this chapter emphasizes
the need for young entrepreneurs to be given appropriate
support and encouragement for self-employment opportunities,
including those in informal sector activities. Such labour
market policy also needs to take into consideration the
rapid urbanization trend found in a number of countries
in Asia and the Pacific and the large number of young people
flowing into the big cities. Rural youth should be given
information and other forms of support so that they are
not easily uprooted from their own community and without
productive job opportunities. The issue of vulnerability
of young people in the labour market needs to be also tackled
through efforts to eliminate child labour, particularly
in its most intolerable forms. At present, the ESCAP region
is home to approximately 61 per cent of the global number
of child labourers.
In terms of the health concerns of young people, issues
of reproductive health and sexuality are highlighted. In
many countries of Asia and the Pacific, adolescents are
neglected in sexual and reproductive health policies and
programmes, despite the fact that many marry during the
early stage of their adolescence. Information and services
to protect them from unwanted pregnancies and sexually transmitted
diseases, including HIV/AIDS, are necessary. It is reported
that more than two million people have been infected with
HIV in the East and South-East Asian subregions, which undoubtedly
will become an even more serious problem in the next century.
The particular vulnerability of young women deserves special
attention in this regard. Further, the prevalent practices
of sexual abuse (rape and incest) and sexual exploitation
(trafficking, pornography and prostitution) in many countries
of Asia require legal and other urgent measures to be taken
on the part of the governments, including subregional and
regional coordination.
Finally, in view of the increasing need for young people
to take charge of their own destiny, as well as the need
for society as a whole to harness the energy and new ideas
of young people, the chapter strongly advocates the need
to promote the participation of young people in decision-making
processes. Formulation and effective implementation of appropriate
youth policies are among the important measures that governments
in the region can undertake to this end. Youth, as a positive
force in the creation of society's future, need to be given
opportunities and support to realize their own aspirations.
REFERENCES
Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific
(ESCAP) (1997). Asia Pacific Population Journal, Vol. 12,
No. 3.______ (1997). Asia Pacific Population Journal, Vol.
12, No. 2.
International Planned Parenthood Federation (IPPF), Undated,
Understanding Adolescents.
Kaime-Atterhoeg (1997). Commercial Sexual Exploitation
of Children: a desk study of the health consequences and
interventions with special reference to developing countries,
unpublished paper.
World Health Organization (WHO) (1993). The Health of Young
People: A Challenge and a Promise, Geneva.
|